Although I now class Peter Jackson's
Lord Of The Rings as one of my favourite movies, I wasn't overly impressed when I first saw
The Fellowship Of The Ring at the cinema. There were too many long shots of people in fancy dress walking through fields and the narrative didn't flow that well. It was only when I saw the extended, director's cut on DVD that I began to appreciate the majesty of Jackson's ambitious enterprise.
So, I suppose there's every possibility that one day I will come to love to
An Unexpected Journey. But I can't see it being any time soon.
One of the major problems I have with it
(beyond being way too long) is it is simply isn't
The Lord Of The Rings. Although there are moments of brilliance in this first, 169-minute segment of
The Hobbit, it lurches from broad comedy to grim dourness with very clumsy footing.
It also becomes very clear that the source material is a book aimed squarely at very young children, with its alliteratively-named dwarvish troupe of adventurers, anachronistic sporting references and trolls named Burt and Tom.
On one hand we have the orc war-band speaking in sub-titles, then we have the trolls and goblins speaking English.
There's no sense that this is a real world, something which the original three movies achieved effortlessly.
There are scenes - such as the gathering of big-wigs at Rivendell - that feel wholly enmeshed in this world we have grown to love, but then there's the stupidly-named trolls (
one also uses a handkerchief) and other moments of juvenilia, that I know are from Tolkien's book, but still don't tally with the flawless verisimilitude of Middle-Earth from
Lord Of The Rings.
The rabbit-drawn sled I can let slide (
I have a soft spot for rabbits), but the preposterous stone giants:
why, just why?
Although there's some meaty exposition up-front, the film starts really slowly with the dwarves arrival at Bag End and the whole set-up for the plot (
could have done without the "That's What Bilbo Baggins Hates" song that came dangerously close to tipping this piece over into high camp).
Then even once the adventurers get going there's a diversion for the audience to visit the nature wizard Radagast The Brown (Sylvester McCoy) which, while visually interesting, takes about quarter-of-an-hour to show us something that Gandalf tells Elrond et al in a couple of lines.
And so it goes on, in fits and starts.
Just as you think the pace is picking up, something will pop up to slow things back down again and the plot doesn't really get flowing until the final act - namely Bilbo (Martin Freeman) playing the 'riddle game' with Gollum (Andy Serkis); the dwarves escape from goblin town (
which in a sense is just a replay of the Fellowship escaping Moria, but with wooden bridges replacing stone); then the fight with the orcs; and finally the arrival of the eagles (
which is handled very well, as it isn't explained because we know exactly what to expect when we see Gandalf talking to the moth he has captured).
Do have to wonder though why the eagles couldn't carry our heroes a bit closer to their final destination?
There are also odd moments where - given that technology has presumably moved on quite a bit since the
Rings films - some of the special effects jarred; there's some quite noticeable green-screening which is always a good way to kick you out of the moment. Is this a side effect of Jackson's use of a higher frame-rate to shoot the movie?
While the director's cuts of all three parts of
Lord Of The Rings are long, they flow gorgeously and never feel like a chore, but the two hours 42 minutes (
plus about seven minutes of credits) of
An Unexpected Journey really felt like a marathon.
It was certainly rewarding once we crossed the finish line, and the final shot of Smaug waking up was worth its weight in gold - but then you have to realise we're only a third of the way.
Perhaps the narrative will flow better when we can watch all three pictures back-to-back and see the full vision that Jackson is bringing to this tale.
There's clearly been a lot of backstory added (
from Tolkien's other work) to build up the story of the Necromancer and create a bridge to
The Lord Of The Rings and I can't help wishing that more emphasis had been put on this and a scalpel had been taken to the actual story of
The Hobbit to strip it back to its core elements.