
It's no secret that the original Smile (from 2022) is one of my favourite creepy movies, for its genuine ability to get under my skin, so I had high hopes for the sequel, Smile 2, released on disc in the UK this week.
Sadly, the film isn't a particularly strong sequel as it mainly retreads a lot of the mythology created in the first movie, seemingly only choosing to build on it right at the last moment. And the suggested implications of this contradict what the established lore of the central demon's M.O.
Personally, I would have liked a story that dug deeper into the backstory of the supernatural parasite at the heart of this franchise, rather than once again going over how it drives its victims insane and feeds off of them.
Picking up the story six days from the end of the first movie, the demonic "Smile" entity is passed on to drug dealer Lewis Fregoli (Lukas Gage).
Meanwhile, global pop sensation, Skye Riley (Naomi Scott) is preparing for a world tour, after a year recovering from a car crash that killed her boyfriend, actor Paul Hudson (Ray Nicholson), and severely injured her.
With a history of substance abuse, Skye finds it hard to obtain legal pain medication and so turns to her dealer... Lewis Fregoli.
Lewis is behaving very strangely when Skye arrives and eventually kills himself - in a particularly gruesome manner - right in front of her.
Soon after, Skye starts to have very vivid, and horrific, hallucinations and is seeing people with twisted smiles plastered across their faces.
While shocking and graphic in places, Smile 2 is slow to get going and I only found myself really getting drawn into the story at the mid-point of the two hour movie.
A lot of the shocks revolve around needles and broken glass, which is quite squirm-inducing, meaning Smile 2 feels more concerned with physical horror than the psychological horror of the first film.
There's a definite air of Emma Roberts around Naomi's portrayal of Skye, and our protagonist could easily have been any number of the self-absorbed, horrible characters that Roberts has played in the American Horror Story franchise.
Skye isn't an easy character to get invested in, and therefore care about.
However, as she plunges deeper into her demon-fuelled psychosis, the film certainly becomes stronger, with one particularly impressive plot twist that reminded me of another of my favourite movies (although I can't say which as that will give the game away).
As Skye is a pop star - and the marketing for this movie brilliantly created a genuine online media presence for the character, from her own Instagram account to music videos - this means there's as much music in Smile 2 as the much maligned Joker: Folie à Deux.
Does this make Smile 2 a musical?
For my money, it's a fun, ultragory, horror tale that rehashes the mythology of its progenitor in a flashy new setting, but falls way short of Smile's unnerving originality.

